Amber Heard, Johnny Depp trial verdict: LA lawyer reveals who will win

0 0
Read Time:5 Minute, 7 Second

A former LA lawyer has predicted the decision of the defamation battle between Amber Heard and Johnny Depp — mentioning one tiny element which will sway the jury.

Because the world waits for the jury within the excessive profile Amber Heard and Johnny Depp defamation trial to deliberate, a former LA lawyer has given her two cents as to the result of each events’ arguments.

The ongoing multimillion-dollar defamation trial involving the 2 actors got here to a detailed after six weeks on Friday native time, after bringing a media frenzy and intense public scrutiny of the couple, their careers and failed marriage earlier than their bitter divorce.

Depp first filed a go well with in opposition to Heard over an op-ed she wrote for The Washington Submit in December 2018 wherein she described herself as a “public determine representing home abuse”.

Heard didn’t identify Depp within the piece, however he sued her for implying he was a home abuser and is in search of US$50 million ($A67m) in damages.

Stream extra leisure information dwell & on demand with Flash. 25+ information channels in 1 place. New to Flash? Attempt 1 month free. Supply ends 31 October, 2022 >

Heard countersued for US$100 million ($A139m), claiming she suffered “rampant bodily violence and abuse.”

Now, the case is within the fingers of jurors.

Former LA District Legal professional and authorized analyst Emily D. Baker, who has been offering YouTube commentary on the widely-followed trial, admitted she was at first satisfied neither Depp or Heard would win the case throughout an interview on the Not Skinny However Not Fats podcast lately.

Nevertheless, she has modified her tune after one key element in Amber Heard’s testimony, main her to consider Depp might win the case.

When she took the stand earlier this month, Aquaman actress Heard confirmed she retweeted the Washington Submit opinion piece she authored in 2018, which included the headline Depp claims is defamatory.

In response to Baker, that is the element that provides Depp’s authorized team a bonus.

“The headline is ‘Opinion Amber Heard: “I spoke up about sexual violence and confronted our tradition’s wrath. This has to alter,” Baker defined.

“Her team has been arguing that she didn’t write the headline. Depp’s team is arguing even when she didn’t write the headline, she retweeted it and stated ‘At the moment I printed this op ed within the Washington Submit concerning the ladies who’re channelling their rage about violence and inequity into political energy regardless of the value of coming ahead’.”

Baker went on to name the tweet the “strongest” a part of Heard’s testimony for Depp’s team.

“So it has the headline in it and he or she’s saying ‘I printed this op ed’. So I believe the tweet is their strongest case proper now as a result of she’s saying ‘I wrote this’ and he or she’s saying ‘I wrote this together with the headline’.

“And in the event that they discover that these allegations should not actual or that they don’t consider them or that they will’t get there to consider in them sufficient to say it’s not defamatory, then these are the strongest counts for him.”

Baker’s views on closing statements

Talking on her YouTube channel, Baker defined why she didn’t assume there was a “path to victory” for both occasion at the start of the trial, however surmised {that a} win for Depp can be believable due to the tweet, calling it “the clearest path” to a win.

“The legislation and the op ed weren’t working for me nicely. And I used to be like ‘That is going to be very, very hard’,” she stated.

“After seeing six weeks of this trial, I perceive why they selected to take this to trial and I see that Johnny Depp has a possible to win.

“And that may be a enormous win, I believe, for them as a result of that wasn’t the place I used to be at at the start of this case.

“So my verdict is that if there’s a win, it’s that. I nonetheless assume this jury may go along with no one wins, I nonetheless assume this jury may cling. I by no means put that apart. I additionally don’t like betting on verdicts, I didn’t do this with my very own verdicts.”

Each events may nonetheless lose

Baker went on to say she may see each events dropping on the defamation claims, however not one occasion successful total.

“The jury can discover no-one is liable, no-one defamed no-one, no-one defamed anybody, no defamation in any respect. Everybody loses,” she defined.

“The jury may discover that one facet wins. I don’t see a path to each side successful on defamation. If you happen to consider that Amber Heard didn’t defame Johnny Depp then you may get to them calling her a hoaxer is the truth is defamatory.

“If you happen to assume she didn’t defame Johnny Depp or in the event you assume that she did defame Johnny Depp then calling her a hoaxer or a liar will not be essentially going to be defamation in your eyes.

“I don’t assume each can win, I believe each can lose,” she concluded.

Baker additionally defined the chance of a hung jury.

“This jury can cling … If there are just a few, one or two no matter on the jury, that consider vehemently one facet or the opposite.

“If you happen to consider Amber Heard lied about Johnny Depp, are you ever going to say ‘No, Amber Heard didn’t defame Johnny Depp.’ And in the event you consider Johnny Depp perpetrated horrific abuse on Amber Heard are you ever going to say ‘No, she defamed Johnny Depp.’ And that’s the place you find yourself with a possible for a hung jury.

“The potential for a hung jury is that in the event you consider one facet strongly, nothing goes to sway you.”

About Post Author

Indonesian News | UK Business Directory

Indopost local UK business directory provides the best in finding 'local businesses near me' for you. In addition, we provide the latest news for Indonesians. We provide local listings, reviews, directions, maps, and contact details. Need more? Ask Stan!
0 %
0 %
0 %
0 %
0 %
0 %
Previous post Dedication predictions for prime 10 uncommitted 2023 D-tackles
Next post Payne Haas, contract, launch, Broncos, administration, replace

Average Rating

5 Star
4 Star
3 Star
2 Star
1 Star

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.